Article Contributed by Philip Andrews
Published on 2026-11-19
Goose | John Paul Jones Arena | November 18th, 2026 - photos by Philip Andrews
Before the show even started, I had my favorite moment of the night. The family parked next to us had a young fan along for his very first concert, and Goose is his favorite band. His parents had told him they were going to a UVA basketball game and that it was fan favorite band night. After the show, I was able to grab a setlist and hand it to him in the parking lot. I don't know who was happier, him or me.


Goose last played Charlottesville on 09/09/2024 at Ting Pavilion, a 3,500-seat outdoor stage. A little over two years later, they came back to a nearly sold-out John Paul Jones Arena, which holds 12,500. Before the first note, Peter Anspach told the crowd it had been a while and that the band had been wanting to get back. The crowd gave them a very warm welcome home.


Doors opened at 7:30, and the band went straight into “Jive II” > “Jive Lee.” That set the tone for the first set. There were no lengthy jams, but the ones that came felt freer, with more room to breathe. “The Whales” and a cover of Ilsey Juber's “No California” followed. “No California” made its first appearance since April 11, 2026, a gap of 72 shows.




The highlight of the first set was “Atlas Dogs” > “Drive” > “Pumped Up Kicks.” The Foster the People cover landed well with the crowd, and “Give It Time” closed out the set.
If the first set was about space, the second was about depth. Set two was one big “Big Modern!” sandwich. It opened with the title track from their latest album, Big Modern!, and the encore closed with the same song. A lot of fans in the arena and online had been wondering whether “Big Modern!” would be left unfinished. Goose didn't let that happen.





The second set was noticeably jam-heavy. Trevor Weekz and Cotter Ellis laid down deep grooves, and Rick Mitarotonda and Peter traded epic riffs over the top. The crowd never got a break because every song blended into the next.
The “Moby” > “POP” > “Creatures” section was the highlight of the night. “Creatures” stretched to a 27-minute jam, with a “Hella Good” tease from Rick along the way. It led perfectly into “The Old Man's Boat,” which closed the set. That was the song's first appearance since April 15, 2026, a gap of 69 shows.

The break before the encore ran noticeably long. Maybe a Super Smash Bros. tiebreak was needed. When the band returned, they opened with “Arcadia,” my wife's favorite song, and it lifted us right off the ground. Then came the closure we'd been waiting for. “Arcadia” flowed into “Big Modern!,” and the band finally finished the song they had opened the second set with.
Going from a 3,500-seat amphitheater to a nearly full arena in just over two years is no small jump, and Goose looked right at home. The band said it wanted to come back, and the room showed how much Charlottesville wanted them back, too. Here's hoping it won't be another two years before they return.
John Paul Jones Arena
Charlottesville, Virginia
Set One:
Jive II > Jive Lee
The Whales
No California (Ilsey Juber cover)
Atlas Dogs > Drive > Pumped Up Kicks (Foster the People cover)
Give It Time
Set Two:
Big Modern! > Moby > POP > Creatures (with “Hella Good” tease from Rick) > The Old Man's Boat
Encore:
Arcadia (unfinished) > Big Modern!